Atypical organophosphate poisoning and a successful case of prolonged intubation in a low-resource newly developed intensive care unit in rural Zambia

  1. Lara Bowell 1 and
  2. Mark Timothy Williams 2
  1. 1 Intensive Care Unit, Katete, Zambia
  2. 2 General Practice - Global Health Fellow, NELFT NHS Foundation Trust, Rainham, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Mark Timothy Williams; drmarkwilliams@icloud.com

Publication history

Accepted:09 Feb 2024
First published:21 Feb 2024
Online issue publication:21 Feb 2024

Case reports

Case reports are not necessarily evidence-based in the same way that the other content on BMJ Best Practice is. They should not be relied on to guide clinical practice. Please check the date of publication.

Abstract

Organophosphate poisoning is a common, under-reported cause of attempted and completed suicide worldwide. Following the resolution of the acute cholinergic syndrome, patients may develop respiratory muscle and proximal limb weakness, known as intermediate syndrome. A young man was brought to our rural hospital unconscious, in extremis, due to organophosphate pesticide poisoning. He developed atypical intermediate syndrome with global paralysis, persistent fasciculations and prolonged cholinergic symptoms, differing from the recognised presentation. He was intubated for fifteen days in our newly developed intensive care unit. Limited treatment options and the absence of blood gases, electrolyte testing, ECGs, invasive monitoring and imaging, in conjunction with regular disruptions to electricity and oxygen, and complications including seizures and pneumonia, all made this prolonged intubation an ambitious and challenging endeavour. We offer learning points for the acute physician and rural intensivist, and a summary of our reflections and hints for best care when adapting to a resource-limited setting.

Background

Worldwide, the impact of deliberate and accidental organophosphate poisoning (OP) is vast and concerning. The mortality burden is estimated at over 13% of global suicides, most of which occur in the developing world.1–3 Data within Africa is scarce as many countries do not report data to the WHO. However, a 2014 systematic review on suicide in the African continent estimated pesticide poisoning as the most common method.4 Within Zambia, a 2016 review of over 800 poisonings that presented to the main teaching hospitals in Lusaka identified pesticides as the most common agent ingested for deliberate self-harm. Eighty per cent of the pesticide poisonings were in patients under 30 years old.5 A review of admissions for OP to our hospital in 2021 (n=115) revealed a mortality rate of 12%.

Organophosphate pesticides are available to the general public in agricultural stores within many developing countries where farming is a common occupation. Organophosphorus compounds are water-soluble and readily absorbed through ingestion, inhalation and transdermally. The main toxicity occurs as they bind to and inactivate acetyl-cholinesterase (AChE) enzymes at nerve terminals. AChE normally breaks down acetylcholine, thus its inactivation leads to an accumulation of acetylcholine at nerve terminals within the peripheral nervous system (at muscarinic and nicotinic receptors) and the central nervous system. If the organophosphate remains bound to the AChE, it will undergo irreversible inactivation, a process called ageing. Following ageing the body must generate new AChE, a process which can take several weeks, during which receptors are exposed to unopposed acetylcholine.6 At the neuromuscular junction (NMJ), this prolonged exposure may lead to persistent depolarisation and desensitisation of postsynaptic nicotinic receptors, leading to weakness.

Within 24 hours of ingestion patients develop a cholinergic syndrome, with both muscarinic and nicotinic manifestations (see table 1), which can cause multifactorial respiratory failure and shock. 24–96 hours after ingestion, after resolution of the cholinergic syndrome, about 10%–40% of patients will develop intermediate syndrome (IMS).2 IMS is characterised by prolonged nicotinic effects at the NMJ with weakness (ocular, bulbar, proximal limb muscles and muscles of respiration) and depressed tendon reflexes. The pathophysiology of IMS is not well understood and other mechanisms including oxidative stress are proposed to play a role.7 During this period, patients require supportive care and some patients require mechanical ventilation for respiratory failure, until IMS spontaneously recovers after 1–3 weeks, with regeneration of new AchE. After IMS resolves, the syndrome of delayed polyneuropathy may occur.

Table 1

Clinical manifestations of the cholinergic syndrome

Muscarinic effects Sweating, lacrimation, urination, diarrhoea, vomiting, bronchoconstriction, miosis, bradycardia, hypotension, arrhythmias
Nicotinic effects Muscle fasciculations, cramps, weakness, paralysis, respiratory compromise, tachycardia
Central nervous system effects Agitation, confusion, tremors, ataxia, seizures, reduced level of consciousness, coma

Overstimulation of the cholinergic nerve terminals by acetylcholine accumulation leads to many of the clinical features of OP, therefore, anti-cholinergic drugs are the mainstay of treatment. Atropine counteracts the effects of excess acetylcholine through competitive inhibition at muscarinic receptors. Atropine is administered in incremental dosing with a target end-point ‘atropinisation’ (this target varies in the literature, but criteria generally include a clear chest (dried secretions) and haemodynamic stability). Atropine toxicity leads to fever, urinary retention, absent bowel sounds, confusion and tachycardia.

Pralidoxime (an oxime) has been shown to regenerate AChE if administered prior to AChE ageing. Pralidoxime is recommended by WHO and commonly administered worldwide, however, its use is controversial.8–10

Case presentation

Intensive care unit

We present background information on our intensive care unit (ICU) resources at the time of this case presentation, to allow our readers to consider how our learning points could apply to their local critical care unit.

The six-bed unit was established in September 2019. Initially intended as a higher acuity ward for improved monitoring (assigned two nurses per shift), the unit subsequently obtained ventilators in March 2020. From then, the hospital has been ventilating medical, surgical and obstetric patients with a dedicated nursing team, but in the absence of a trained critical care physician. In mid-2021, the unit began the use of non-invasive ventilation, sedation (propofol or ketamine, via syringe driver) and inotropic support (epinephrine or dopamine when available, peripherally administered via infusion pump).

We were not able to provide dialysis on-site, or perform central venous access, invasive blood pressure monitoring, end-tidal CO2, blood gases or electrolyte tests. Opiates were unavailable and the supply of all medications could be disrupted at times. Masks, airway equipment and circuit tubing were cleaned and reused. Due to regular electricity outages, the hospital relied on a backup generator, however, there were still periods without electricity. We were reliant on concentrators and cylinder oxygen, however, since late-2021, an oxygen plant has been established at the hospital (supported by solar panels), supplying piped oxygen to some wards.

Of the 12 nurses on the ICU rota, 4 had previously worked in an ICU. In 2020, the whole team received two training sessions covering the new ventilators. This was provided by the ministry of health and the central teaching hospital in Lusaka. New nurses joining since then have been trained in turn by the nursing head of the department.

Case presentation

A man in his 30s was admitted after an intentional ingestion of approximately 100 mL of organophosphate pesticide 3 hours prior to admission. He displayed acute cholinergic symptoms with vomiting, diarrhoea, urinary incontinence, sweating and high-volume respiratory secretions. The specific compound he ingested was dichlorvos (2,2-dichlorovinyl dimethyl phosphate), a class 1B ‘highly hazardous’ chemical as per the WHO, sales of which are restricted or banned in many countries.11

On arrival to the ward, he was unconscious with a glasgow coma scale (GCS) of 3/15, copious airway secretions and a poor respiratory effort, bradycardic (central pulse 50–60 bpm) with an unrecordable blood pressure and a blood sugar of 2.5 mmol/L. Family removed his soiled clothes and washed him. He received ventilation via a bag- valve- mask with 10L of oxygen to achieve 77% saturations (maximum oxygen capacity via our oxygen concentrator), incremental atropine and epinephrine boluses, intravenous fluids and dextrose. He was transferred to the ICU and intubated for airway protection and respiratory failure via rapid sequence induction. A 1.5 mg/kg dose of suxamethonium (100 mg) was used, in the absence of an alternative muscle relaxant.

He was the second patient to present with an OP that evening, and as such the hospital atropine supply was depleted. Despite 70 mg of atropine, we achieved suboptimal atropinisation and he required an epinephrine infusion for haemodynamic stability. In the absence of invasive monitoring, his blood pressure was monitored with a manual sphygmomanometer, shared between ICU patients. He also received 20 mmol of intravenous magnesium over 4 hours within the first 24 hours and was commenced on metronidazole and ceftriaxone due to aspiration.

Twelve hours postadmission, his GCS and haemodynamics improved and he no longer required inotropes. However, within hours, he developed resistant status epilepticus, which did not terminate despite 40 mg intravenous diazepam, followed by nasogastric phenobarbitone loading (our only available anticonvulsants). Additionally, he had worsening high-volume respiratory secretions, bradycardia and hypotension. More atropine was sourced by family and the hospital, and he was commenced on an infusion titrated to end points of a dry chest, mean arterial pressure >60 mm Hg and pulse >80 bpm. Despite an escalating dose of atropine, he had pinpoint pupils, respiratory secretions, high-volume diarrhoea, fluctuating GCS and intermittent seizure activity with no spontaneous breaths on minimal sedation.

Ninety-six hours postingestion, he became alert, could protect his airway and ventilate spontaneously. We noted muscle fasciculations, however, given the risks of ongoing ventilation in a resource-limited setting, we attempted his first extubation. He rapidly developed progressive descending weakness and was commenced on bilevel positive airway pressure (BIPAP) with a likely diagnosis of IMS. He was stable and alert for 7 hours, he then lost consciousness and was re-intubated without suxamethonium.

Over the next 13 days, he had ongoing nicotinic symptoms of fasciculations, deep tendon areflexia and near global paralysis except for minimal eye (from day 7), head, toe and finger movement (from day 8), as well as prolonged muscarinic symptoms of high-volume diarrhoea and respiratory secretions. He intermittently required atropine (until day 11) to control the respiratory secretions, however, when administered he displayed signs of toxicity (tachycardia and fever). He was actively cooled, and we used the lowest effective dose of atropine infusion to avoid fever. This would be stopped when secretions became manageable. His bloods returned WCC (white cell count) 11.4 x109/L, Hb (heamaglobin) 12.9 g/dL, AST (aspartate aminotransferase) 55 U/L, ALT (alanine transaminase) 31 U/L and creatinine 98 μmol/L. A malaria rapid diagnostic test and COVID-19 lateral flow test were negative. He remained alert (E4VTM6), with low-dose propofol sedation in the day and sedation to allow sleep at night. He was managed mostly on volume-control synchronised intermittent mandatory ventilation. Our focus during this period was on reducing complications. He received early bolus enteral nutrition to prevent ileus, maintain gut integrity and as stress ulcer prophylaxis12; omeprazole; 4 days of heparin prophylaxis (as available); physiotherapy; analgesia; regular mouth care to reduce ventilator-associated pneumonia; and was managed head up with rotation to reduce pressure sores and to interact with staff and family. With ongoing fluid losses and in the absence of electrolytes we used a four-lead ECG to screen for significant potassium derangement, monitored urinary specific gravity and did our best to normalise electrolytes with judicious use of oral rehydration solution (ORS), a tactic we have used for several patients in this rural ICU who likely had profound electrolyte abnormalities.

We commenced the first ventilation weaning at this hospital with stepwise reduced ventilatory support. Prolonged respiratory paralysis due to IMS and the absence of blood gases made this challenging, but vital to reduce ventilator-associated muscle weakness and complications. Ten days after intubation, he had a gradual ascending resolution of paralysis, though respiratory muscle fasciculations and weakness persisted. This was complicated by a likely ventilator-associated pneumonia, common in this setting of reused equipment (diagnosed clinically due to lack of mobile imaging).

We attempted extubation again on day 11 as he could generate spontaneous breaths of 5–6 mL/kg and had a cough reflex. He was initially stable for 3 hours on BIPAP, before becoming haemodynamically unstable and unconscious, and was reintubated without suxamethonium. Over the following 5 days, his respiratory muscle power and fasciculations improved.

On day 15 of ventilation, after a challenging 24 hours of oxygen failures and electricity cuts, sometimes lasting several hours, during which the nurses would hand-ventilate the patient through the endotracheal tube, he was successfully extubated onto oxygen. We approximated intensive chest physiotherapy by encouraging him to inflate a surgical glove to reduce alveolar collapse and encourage respiratory muscle work out (figure 1).

Figure 1

Using a glove for physiotherapy.

He had ongoing physiotherapy, nutrition and psychiatric involvement. He was discharged on antidepressants after 21 days in the hospital.

Outcome and follow-up

The patient was reviewed at 3 months in his home in a rural village 3 km from the hospital. He sat with his wife and four young children around him. He described himself as ‘strong’ with no long-lasting deficits. He had stopped antidepressants of his own accord after 1 month but was well in mood. On examination, there was no neurological deficit noted. He had returned to the intensive farming that provided his living.

Global health problem list

There are limited published case reports of the clinical presentation and challenges of managing a patient with a severe OP requiring prolonged intubation in Africa.

Atypical complex presentations require thoughtful clinical acumen in the absence of established guidelines.

Resource limitation—This includes less access to investigations, medications and equipment.

Global health problem analysis

There are many documented cases on management of OP, however, we could not find another published case of successful prolonged intubation for IMS in a rural African setting. We hope this stands as an encouraging example of the possibilities of basic intensive care in district hospitals.

Additionally, we wished to highlight this atypical OP presentation with a prolonged cholinergic phase and a global paralysis during the IMS. The recognised presentation of OP in literature describes IMS causing proximal weakness involving the ocular, bulbar, proximal limb muscles and muscles of respiration which occurs following cessation of cholinergic symptoms and fasciculations.2 In our case, despite an initial resolution of muscarinic symptoms as expected after the acute cholinergic phase, we witnessed further, prolonged muscarinic features (respiratory secretions and diarrhoea) to day 11. This cholinergic phase persisted well beyond the start of the clinical features of IMS. Second, during the paralysis of IMS, we witnessed a complete paralysis including distal lower and upper limbs even encompassing fine movements of the digits. We also observed persistent nicotinic fasciculations throughout (typically these would resolve after the cholinergic phase). Whether these were all a direct result of OP toxicity or an alternative unknown complication within this unpredictable setting, it adds to our understanding of managing a patient with OP and IMS within a resource-limited hospital.

Deciding to intubate in this setting is fraught with difficulties and the risk–benefit analysis is not the same as it would be in a higher-resource setting. Mortality is a likely outcome even with best care. There may be safer options for respiratory failure if available, such as high-flow oxygen or non-invasive ventilation. However, in patients who unequivocally require intubation, measures can be taken to mitigate risk and achieve successful outcomes. While national guidelines cover standard care of OP,13 we had to make decisions on a clinical basis and in accordance with any available resources. Clinical pointers that we would most recommend to other rural critical care practitioners managing severe OP include:

  • Use of intravenous epinephrine: Epinephrine is not a commonly recommended medication in the management of OP. However, recent publications14 and our case support the use in atropine-resistant bradycardia and haemodynamic instability or as a temporary measure in the absence of adequate atropine supply. Prescribers must be aware of the consequence of masking inadequate resuscitation and atropinisation, as this should be prioritised.

  • Use of intravenous magnesium sulfate: Various studies have also proposed beneficial effects in OP such as bronchodilation and prevention of tachyarrhythmias in organophosphate-associated QT-elongation. Magnesium is an inhibitor of acetylcholine in the central nervous system and at sympathetic and parasympathetic junctions in the peripheral nervous system. More convincingly, there is evidence for reduced mortality and length of hospital stay when magnesium is administered.15 Lastly, of most benefit to the rural medic is its widespread availability (as an essential medicine for eclampsia).

  • Use of ORS: The evidence for ORS in acute diarrhoea is overwhelming.16 It is primarily for infectious diarrhoea, although is commonly used regardless of proven infection. We could find only one small study supporting use of ORS within an ICU setting17 and none specifically in ventilated patients. Additionally, we could find no evidence for their use in OP or as a source of maintenance electrolytes for an unconscious patient with diarrhoea when electrolyte monitoring and parenteral feeding are unavailable. If used in this way, we would suggest that clinicians are aware of the difference between standard and low osmolarity preparations18 and that they check the glucose, sodium and potassium contents of their institution’s ORS product. We based our dosing on outstanding fluid requirements after accounting for intravenous fluids and enteral feeding (porridge with salt and sugar added as per local practice delivered via nasogastric tube). We also gave 250 mL per loose stool as per WHO ‘treatment plan A’19 for diarrhoea. On reflection, it may have been preferable to calculate daily electrolyte requirements and offer an amount that matches these requirements (plus estimated diarrhoeal losses) as closely as possible.

  • Consideration of early use of anticonvulsants: The evidence for benzodiazepine use in OP-induced seizures is limited to case reports and animal studies showing improved mortality when given in addition to atropine.20 The other locally available anticonvulsant was phenobarbitone, a WHO essential medication. Again, evidence of reduction in neuronal toxicity from OP-induced refractory status epilepticus is limited to animal studies.21 In our case, onset of status epilepticus coincided with unavailability of atropine and once established was challenging to terminate. On reflection, in a safely intubated patient with profound central nervous system depression due to OP, despite the weak evidence base, we would administer preconvulsive anticonvulsants.

  • A lack of evidence for oximes: A high proportion of OP cases are in low-income countries where oximes may be unavailable. As pralidoxime is recommended by the WHO but was not available to us locally, we reviewed the evidence for its use. Several meta-analyses (including Cochrane) found no evidence for the use of oximes and suggested they may even cause harm despite their theorised beneficial mechanism of action.9 10 Cochrane states clearly that the WHO recommendation is not supported in all subgroups. The varying response may be accounted for by differences in the dose, timing and type of organophosphorus compound ingested, along with the dose and timing of oxime administration. It is unclear whether early oxime use would have reduced the duration and severity of symptoms for our patient. We feel that a large randominsed controlled trial must be undertaken to clarify if the WHO-recommended pralidoxime regimen is beneficial, has no clear benefit or is causing harm, and if there are subgroups of OP for whom an oxime could improve outcomes.

  • Effect of organophosphate on succinylcholine (suxamethonium): Suxamethonium is a nicotinic agonist at the neuromotor junction. In normal circumstances, it is rapidly hydrolysed by AChE. As such, a consequence of organophosphate-induced AChE depletion is that suxamethonium-induced paralysis is prolonged, potentially for hours.22 This is important to know in cases of failed intubation and when setting the ventilator.

  • Ventilator modes: With the respiratory paralysis of IMS and without blood gases, our aim was to reduce the effort of triggering breaths and use the patient’s internal respiratory compensation to manage his acid-base balance and ventilation. We used volume-control ventilation (predominantly synchronised intermittent mandatory ventilation) with tidal volumes 7 mL/kg (based on ideal body weight) and a peak end-expiratory pressure of 5 cm water. The minimum mandatory respiratory rate was varied based on spontaneous triggers and as his respiratory paralysis improved. We reduced the flow trigger allowing his limited muscle power to trigger an increased number of spontaneous breaths. Expedited weaning should be a priority to reduce complications, iatrogenic harm and muscle weakness.

  • Use of early physiotherapy: During IMS prolonged muscle paralysis leads to significant muscle wasting and potential complications including deep vein thrombosis, pressure ulcers and pneumonia. We were lucky to have physiotherapists available at the hospital though they had never worked within the ICU. In rural settings, medics and even the family need to be prepared to assist in adjunctive but essential therapies like physiotherapy.

Patient’s perspective

‘I am grateful to be alive. I am glad for my children. Please keep trying with the difficult cases, even when you think they will die.’

Learning points

  • For the intubated patient in a resource-limited setting, many aspects of care are beyond control. Simple measures to reduce complications and improve outcomes include; early enteral feeding and electrolyte replacement with oral rehydration solution, early and diligent physiotherapy, positioning to avoid pressure ulcers, mouth care and preparing for unexpected electricity and oxygen cuts.

  • Cholinergic features can recur many days after ingestion, and even during the intermediate syndrome (IMS), requiring a prolonged atropine infusion.

  • Lack of availability of an oxime within rural hospitals should not discourage practitioners, as it is not fundamental to achieving a successful outcome in severe organophosphate poisoning (OP).

  • Patients may require weeks of ventilatory support due to respiratory failure from IMS but even lengthy supportive care can have successful outcomes.

Ethics statements

Patient consent for publication

Acknowledgments

We would like to acknowledge the support of St Francis Hospital, particularly the medical and intensive care departments.

Footnotes

  • Contributors LB and MTW are the joint and sole authors of this case report. LB conceived the report. LB and MTW jointly researched, referenced, wrote and edited the case report. MTW is corresponding author.

  • Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

  • Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

References

Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer